Plano or McKinney: Which One Fits Your Move?

Plano or McKinney: Which One Fits Your Move?

November 15, 2026•13 min read
Plano or McKinney: Which One Fits Your Move?

Most of the people who ask me to compare Plano and McKinney have just accepted a job at a Plano or Frisco campus. They like the idea of more house farther north, but they want to know what the extra miles really cost them. Both cities are big, safe, well managed, and share a border in Collin County. So the choice rarely comes down to which one is "better." It comes down to how old you want your house to be, how far you're willing to drive, and how much change you can tolerate around you.

Here's the one paragraph version. Plano is mature, mostly built out, served by light rail, and full of corporate headquarters. McKinney is still adding thousands of homes, has a genuine 19th century downtown, and posts a higher median household income, but most of the large employers are south of it. On price and tax rate, the two are much closer than people assume.

I'm a REALTOR and a mortgage loan originator with NEXA Mortgage, so below I'll walk through jobs, commute, housing, taxes, schools, and growth, with the source and month next to every number, and I'll point out where the difference actually moves a monthly payment.

Quick answer: If your office is at Legacy or along the Plano corporate corridor and you want rail access, Plano makes more sense. If you want newer construction, a walkable historic square, and more space per dollar, McKinney does. West McKinney near SH 121 is the compromise that commutes most like Plano.

Head to Head Snapshot

Item

Plano

McKinney

Residents at the 2020 Census

285,494

195,308

NCTCOG estimate for January 1, 2025

299,262

226,181

Population change from 2020 to 2025

About 4.8%

About 15.8%

Redfin median sale and yearly change

$499,762, three months ending September 2026, down 3.0%

$511,000, August 2026, down 3.5%

Redfin price per square foot

$212

$202

Redfin median days on market

43

49

Census median household income, 2020 to 2024

$112,253

$124,215

Adults 25 and older with a bachelor's or higher

60.5%

54.1%

Share of homes occupied by owners

56.9%

63.8%

Average commute

25.4 minutes

27.8 minutes

Main district and TEA grade

Plano ISD, B (82) for 2024 to 2025

McKinney ISD, B (87) for 2025 to 2026

On DART light rail

Yes

No

Keep two caveats in mind. The Redfin months don't match because each city's page showed a different reporting period when I pulled them on October 28, 2026. And the TEA grades come from different school years, so read them as a ballpark rather than a true head to head.

Start With Where You Work

Plano's job base

Plano is one of the region's biggest employment hubs. The newest verified list of top employers I found is the city's 2020 financial report, which showed JPMorgan Chase with 4,934 workers, Capital One with 4,537, Bank of America with 4,500, and Toyota Motor North America with 3,815, with NTT Data, Ericsson, Liberty Mutual, and others further down. Those headcounts are six years old and have certainly shifted, but the corporate concentration hasn't. Census data puts Plano's average commute at 25.4 minutes.

McKinney's job base

McKinney isn't a bedroom community. Raytheon counted more than 3,000 people locally at the time of its 2019 expansion announcement. Globe Life put its McKinney workforce above 2,000 in February 2025, and Prysmian said in April 2026 that Encore Wire's McKinney campus employs roughly 1,750. Even so, plenty of residents with office jobs head south every morning, and the city's average commute is 27.8 minutes. I go deeper on local employers in jobs and employers in McKinney.

The part of McKinney you choose matters most

From the west side near SH 121 and Lake Forest Dr, Google Maps put Legacy West about 20 minutes away on a weekday afternoon in October 2026. From east McKinney, the same trip was closer to 35 minutes. That 15 minute swing inside one city is often bigger than the gap between the two cities' averages.

Rail, Roads, and Runways

Plano belongs to DART and has light rail. The Silver Line began service on October 25, 2025, with Plano stops at 12th Street and Shiloh Road and a direct connection to DFW Airport. The city had set a May 2026 election on withdrawing from DART, then called it off on February 23, 2026 after striking a deal with the agency.

McKinney has no DART service, so you'll drive. What it's getting instead is a commercial airport close to home. Avelo Airlines is scheduled to begin flying out of McKinney National Airport (DTX) sometime between November 11 and 19, 2026, from a new 46,000 square foot terminal, with nonstops planned to Orlando, Tampa, Fort Myers, Fort Lauderdale, and Las Vegas. The route map is short, but for anyone in north Collin County it beats the trek to DFW or Love Field.

The Houses Themselves

McKinney: new builds plus a century of styles

For August 2026, Redfin put McKinney's median at $511,000, 3.5% below the prior year, or about $202 a square foot. What stands out is how much is still being built. The city's 2024 Annual Development Report recorded a record 2,310 single family permits that year, led by Painted Tree and Trinity Falls. Buying a brand new house in McKinney takes little effort, and builders are still competing for buyers; incentives change month to month, so ask what's current.

The age range is wide too. You'll find Victorians from the 1880s and 1890s close to the downtown square, brick homes from the 1990s and 2000s in Stonebridge Ranch and Eldorado Heights, and fresh master planned communities on the north side. I cover what each era looks like in my McKinney architecture and home types post.

Plano: mostly resale, closer in

Plano's Redfin median was $499,762 for the three months through September 2026, 3.0% lower than the year before, at $212 a square foot. Since the city is largely built out, nearly everything for sale is a resale home, and listings move slightly faster (a 43 day median versus 49). Similar medians plus a higher price per square foot usually means a bit less house for the money, and the trade is a more central address.

PJ's take: if a new build or a newer home on a bigger lot is the priority, McKinney has far more inventory. If mature trees and an established street near the office matter more, Plano has the edge. Compare current listings on my Plano page and my McKinney page.

Property Taxes Are Almost a Wash

This surprises nearly everyone I work with. Inside city limits, the combined base rates land within a hair of each other.

Rate per $100 of value

Plano, inside city limits with Plano ISD

McKinney, inside city limits with McKinney ISD

School district

1.03275, proposed in July 2026 for 2026 to 2027

1.0664, adopted for 2026; roughly 1.0347 if the voter approved portion fails

City

0.4376, adopted for 2025; the city proposed keeping it for FY 2026 to 2027

0.412284, adopted for 2026

Collin County

0.151414

0.151414

Collin College

0.081220

0.081220

Total, approximate

About 1.70

About 1.71

The McKinney ISD figure depends on the November 3, 2026 tax rate election, so check the result. Before exemptions, a $500,000 house works out to about $8,515 a year in Plano and about $8,557 in McKinney. Plano also grants a 20% city homestead exemption, which trims the city portion for owner occupants. Plano's final 2026 city and school rates weren't something I could confirm, so use your actual tax statement as the final word.

The real tax trap in McKinney isn't the city rate. It's a McKinney mailing address that sits outside the City of McKinney. Trinity Falls owners pay a MUD in place of the city rate. Simpson Crossing and Eastridge carry McKinney addresses but are inside Lowry Crossing and Princeton, with PID assessments stacked on top. From a lending standpoint, I underwrite the payment using the full rate for the specific parcel, because that's what your escrow will collect. The full breakdown lives in my McKinney tax bill explainer.

Schools and Enrollment Trends

McKinney ISD

TEA rated McKinney ISD a B (87) for 2025 to 2026, and each of its three high schools earned an A. Here's the wrinkle: large parts of McKinney aren't in McKinney ISD at all. Most of Craig Ranch belongs to Frisco ISD, its eastern edge is in Allen ISD, and a big share of northwest McKinney, including Tucker Hill, the newer Westridge sections, Aster Park, and Highland Lakes, is in Prosper ISD. Check every address.

The district is also adjusting to where families are moving. Back in November 2025, trustees approved closing and repurposing three southwest elementary campuses, since growth is concentrated in the north and northeast and the southwest campuses have empty seats.

Plano ISD

Plano ISD earned a B (82) for 2024 to 2025, and its enrollment is shrinking. The board approved four campus closures in 2024. In January 2026, a district demographer said enrollment had dropped by 2,712 students for 2025 to 2026 and could fall under 40,000 by 2029 to 2030. Falling enrollment doesn't make the schools worse, but it does raise the odds of more closures and boundary changes.

Downtowns, Dining, and Weekends

McKinney: for many buyers, the historic square is the deciding factor. It's a real downtown from the 1800s with independent shops, restaurants, and festivals, not a built from scratch shopping district. The city also reports about 80 miles of trails and close to 3,000 acres of parks. East of downtown, things are changing fast, with the new municipal complex and Tupps Brewery settling into the old grain site.

Plano: Legacy West and the Shops at Legacy cover dining and retail, Historic Downtown Plano sits right on the DART line, and established restaurants are spread across the whole city. When the goal is maximum choice within ten minutes of home, Plano usually comes out ahead. When the goal is a downtown with personality and a smaller town feel, McKinney usually does.

Growth: Blessing and Headache

NCTCOG figures show McKinney growing about 15.8% between 2020 and January 2025, versus about 4.8% in Plano. The Census Bureau's July 1, 2025 estimate for McKinney was already 236,001. For McKinney, that growth means new schools, new retail, and new roads, along with construction traffic and some large projects. TxDOT's planned US 380 bypass across north McKinney is designed as an eight lane controlled access freeway, and the first project is expected to be awarded in 2027. On the east side, the Spur 399 widening got underway in 2025. I track those projects in my post on McKinney areas on the rise.

Plano's change is slower and mostly redevelopment and infill. You get more stability, but also aging houses that will need roofs, windows, and kitchens sooner.

Scorecard

If this matters most to you

Edge

Why

New construction or a newer home

McKinney

Record permit volume and many active builders

Short drive to corporate campuses

Plano

Jobs are in town; shorter average commute

Light rail and a rail link to DFW

Plano

DART member with Silver Line stations

Historic downtown with character

McKinney

An authentic 19th century square

Square footage per dollar

McKinney

Lower price per square foot

Mature trees and settled streets

Plano

Established, built out neighborhoods

Predictable tax bill

Plano

Fewer MUD and PID surprises outside city limits

Nearby commercial flights

McKinney

DTX service starting November 2026

Fewer school closures ahead

Unclear

Both districts are closing campuses for different reasons

My Recommendation by Buyer Type

Go with McKinney if you want new construction or a newer house, you'd enjoy living near a walkable historic downtown, you work in north Frisco, Allen, or McKinney itself, or you'd trade a few extra minutes in the car for more space.

Go with Plano if your office is at Legacy, in north Dallas, or along one of Plano's corporate corridors, rail access appeals to you, or you like established neighborhoods and don't mind updating an older home.

Split the difference in west McKinney near SH 121, which includes Craig Ranch, Eldorado Heights, and Westridge. My Craig Ranch page has the details if that's on your list.

Questions I Hear About Plano vs McKinney

Which city costs more to buy into?

It's close. Redfin had McKinney at a $511,000 median for August 2026 and Plano at $499,762 for the three months through September 2026. Plano runs higher per square foot ($212 against $202), so McKinney typically gets you a bit more house.

Will my tax bill be lower in one of them?

Inside city limits, barely. Plano with Plano ISD comes to about 1.70 per $100 at the proposed 2026 rate, against about 1.71 for McKinney with McKinney ISD. The bigger swing comes from MUDs and PIDs on McKinney address homes outside city limits.

Can a McKinney address put me in a different school district?

Yes, often. Most of Craig Ranch is Frisco ISD, its east side is Allen ISD, and much of northwest McKinney is Prosper ISD. Confirm the district for the exact address before you write an offer.

When do commercial flights start at McKinney's airport?

Avelo is scheduled to start service from DTX between November 11 and 19, 2026, with five nonstop routes. McKinney has no DART rail, so the airport is its main new transportation option.

What does the drive from McKinney to Legacy look like?

From west McKinney near SH 121, about 20 minutes on an October 2026 weekday afternoon per Google Maps. From the east side, around 35 minutes, and peak rush hour adds more.

Is Plano ISD closing more schools?

It's possible. The board approved four closures in 2024, and a demographer told the district in January 2026 that enrollment could slip under 40,000 by 2029 to 2030. Ask about boundary plans for any Plano home you're serious about.

Does Plano offer a homestead exemption?

Yes. Plano gives a 20% city homestead exemption to owner occupants, which lowers the city portion of the bill. Check your appraisal district record to make sure it's applied.

Run the Comparison on Real Addresses

Tell me where you'll be working, your budget, and your top priorities. I'll send a short list of neighborhoods in both Plano and McKinney, and because I handle the financing too, each one comes with an estimated monthly payment that includes taxes and HOA dues for that specific address. Call or text me at 469-817-6060, or send a note through my contact page.

Sources: Housing data from Redfin for Plano and McKinney. Population from NCTCOG's 2025 estimates and Census QuickFacts for Plano and McKinney. Tax rates from the Collin County Tax Assessor, McKinney ISD's 2026 election page, the City of Plano budget site, the Murphy Monitor on Plano ISD's proposed rate, and Community Impact on Plano's 2025 to 2026 rate and its 2026 to 2027 proposal. Schools from Community Impact coverage of Plano ISD's rating, Plano ISD enrollment, Plano ISD closures, and McKinney ISD closures. Employers from the Dallas Morning News list of Plano employers, Dallas Innovates on Raytheon, Globe Life's headquarters release, and Prysmian's Encore Wire release. Transit and growth from Wikipedia's Silver Line entry, KPRC on the canceled Plano DART vote, the City of McKinney on Avelo at DTX, the McKinney 2024 Annual Development Report, and Community Impact on the US 380 bypass. Drive times from Google Maps, October 28, 2026.

PJ Zaji

PJ Zaji

PJ Zaji, Dallas-Fort Worth Realtor and Texas mortgage loan originator

Back to Blog