Buying new construction in Prosper TX guide cover, new brick home in a master-planned community

Buying New Construction in Prosper TX: A Lender's Guide

November 20, 2026•8 min read

Updated November 2026 by PJ Zaji, REALTOR and Mortgage Loan Originator

Short answer: Buying new construction in Prosper, TX in late 2026 usually means a builder home in Star Trail, StarView, Wandering Creek at Brookhollow or Windsong Ranch, with posted builder pricing from about $730,000 to more than $1.4 million. Prosper has far fewer MUD and PID districts than Celina, but you still need to confirm each lot before you sign.

I sit on both sides of a new-build purchase. As a REALTOR I negotiate the builder contract, and as a loan originator I build the loan file that has to close on the builder's schedule. Most of the surprises I see in Prosper come from the gap between those two jobs: a buyer picks a lot and a plan, then finds out later what the payment really is. This guide is how I close that gap for my clients.

How Much Do New Homes in Prosper Cost Right Now?

On November 20, 2026, the Prosper new construction search on Expand Realty showed 113 homes listed, a median list price of $1,165,096, about $283 per square foot and an average of 122 days on the site. That is higher than the citywide median of $1,004,654 across all 460 Prosper listings, because new homes here lean toward larger plans on wider lots.

Builder price sheets tell a more detailed story. These are the posted ranges I pulled on November 20, 2026:

Builder and community

Posted range

Highland Homes, Star Trail (55, 65 and 86 foot lots)

$730,000 to $1,430,000

Highland Homes, StarView

$890,000 to $1,220,000

Toll Brothers, Star Trail

From $1,056,995 (3,244 to 4,940 sq ft)

Toll Brothers, Wandering Creek at Brookhollow

Upper $900,000s (3,750 to 6,175 sq ft)

Inside Highland's Star Trail range, the lot width drives a lot of the price: 55 foot lots ran $730,000 to $910,000, 65 foot lots $850,000 to $990,000, and 86 foot lots $1,150,000 to $1,430,000. Highland also lists Mirabella and Mirabella Huntington in Prosper, but no prices were posted when I checked.

Which Builders and Communities Should I Look At?

Here is how I sort Prosper's new-build options for a client who walks in with a budget:

  • Star Trail: a west Prosper master plan of roughly 800 to 900 acres off the Dallas North Tollway at Prosper Trail, planned for about 1,800 homes. Toll Brothers, Highland Homes and Coventry Homes have built here. It had 82 listings on November 20, the most of any Prosper community.

  • Windsong Ranch: about 2,000 acres in west Prosper along Teel Parkway, developed by Tellus Group around a five-acre Crystal Lagoon. Coventry Homes, Bloomfield Homes and custom builders in the estate sections have built here. It had 60 listings.

  • Brookhollow: Toll's Wandering Creek section, plus Shaddock Homes in Brookhollow West.

  • Shaddock Homes: Brookhollow West, Creekside Estates and Park Place on 80 foot lots. Park Place had 29 listings.

  • Smaller names: Drees at Legacy Gardens, Southgate at Prosper Ridge, and Coventry's Creekside, which was listed as coming soon in our research.

Builder lineups change as sections sell out, so treat this as a starting list, not a final one.

Do Prosper New Builds Come With a MUD or PID?

Less often than in Celina, which is one reason Prosper's sticker prices and tax bills are easier to compare. The Collin County Tax Assessor's 2026 list of special districts does not include any MUD or PID with a Prosper community name, while it lists more than a dozen PIDs named after Celina communities.

Two community-level notes:

  • The Star Trail developer's 2024 HOA and tax sheet says the community uses town water and has no MUD or PID fees.

  • Windsong Ranch sits on the Denton County side. Its tax FAQ from 2019 said residents paid only city, school and county taxes, but that document is old. I always ask for the seller's MUD and PID notices on each home before we write an offer.

Without a special district, a Prosper home in Prosper ISD on the Collin County side carries a combined 2026 rate of about $1.938734 per $100 before exemptions.

Why Does the Tax Bill Jump After Year One?

This is the question I get most from Prosper new-build buyers, usually about 14 months after closing. In the year you close, the appraisal district may have valued the lot as land only or as a partly built house. The next year it values the finished home, and your escrow account is suddenly short.

Here is what that can look like on a $1,165,096 home, the November 2026 new-construction median, using 2026 rates:

Scenario

Estimated yearly tax

Full value, no homestead exemption

About $22,588

Full value, homestead exemption filed

About $19,599

When I set up your loan, I do not let the first escrow estimate rest on a land-only tax figure. I estimate taxes on the finished value so your payment does not jump later, and I remind you to file your homestead exemption with Collin CAD once you live in the home on January 1.

How Do I Use Builder Incentives Without Overpaying?

Prosper builders often offer an incentive tied to their preferred lender: closing costs, a rate buydown, or upgrades. These can be worth real money. But the only fair way to compare them is with the full loan estimate, including the APR, side by side. A lower rate with higher fees, or a bigger upgrade package on a higher base price, can cost you more over the years you actually keep the loan.

My approach:

  1. Get the builder's incentive in writing, with the expiration date.

  2. Ask what part of it requires the builder's lender and what part applies to any lender.

  3. Compare two official loan estimates on the same date, same loan type and same lock period.

  4. Decide on the numbers, not on the gift card.

I go deeper on this in my guide to builder incentives in DFW. Loan approval is never guaranteed, and the right choice depends on your income, credit and how long you plan to stay.

Should I Bring My Own Agent to a Prosper Model Home?

Yes, and on the first visit. Most builders require your agent to be with you or registered at the first visit, or they will not work with that agent later. The sales consultant represents the builder. Your agent represents you on the contract, the lot premium, the upgrade budget, the inspection schedule and the closing date.

Builder contracts in Texas are the builder's own forms, not the standard TREC resale contract. They often limit what you can negotiate after signing and set the deposit terms in the builder's favor. I read every page before you sign. That is where my experience with builder contracts and financing does the most good, not at the front door of the model.

Is the Tollway Extension a Factor?

For west and north Prosper, yes. NTTA's Phase 4A extension of the Dallas North Tollway from US-380 to FM 428 is targeted for late 2027. Star Trail already has its main entrance on the Tollway at Prosper Trail. When you compare two lots, ask how far each one is from the corridor, both for drive time and for road noise.

Ready to Price Your Prosper New Build?

Send me the community, plan and lot you are considering. I will give you a written estimate of the full monthly payment, taxes and HOA included, and a list of questions for the builder. Start with my Prosper, TX area guide, browse Prosper homes for sale, see the loan options on my mortgage page, read the Prosper cost of living breakdown, or contact me directly.

Shopping by builder and community? The Expand Realty team lists every Prosper builder with price ranges and live counts in New Construction Homes in Prosper TX: 2026 Builder Guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the median price of a new home in Prosper, TX?

On November 20, 2026, the median list price of new construction homes in Prosper was $1,165,096 across 113 listings, at about $283 per square foot (Expand Realty MLS data).

Does Star Trail in Prosper have a MUD or PID?

The developer's 2024 HOA and tax sheet says Star Trail uses town water and has no MUD or PID fees. Still review the seller's notices for the exact home.

Can I use my own lender instead of the builder's lender?

Yes. Some incentives only apply with the builder's preferred lender, so compare both official loan estimates, with the APR, on the same day before you choose.

Why did my Prosper property taxes go up the year after I bought a new home?

The first bill is often based on land or a partly built house. The next year the appraisal district values the finished home, so the bill and your escrow payment can rise sharply.

Do I need my own agent to buy from a builder in Prosper?

You don't have to, but the builder's sales team works for the builder. Bring or register your agent on the first visit, because many builders won't recognize an agent added later.

PJ Zaji, REALTOR, Monument Realty (TREC #631862), team Expand Realty Group, 3620 The Star Blvd, Suite 1205, Frisco, TX 75034. Mortgage Loan Originator NMLS# 2280005, NEXA Mortgage, LLC NMLS# 1660690. This is general information, not tax or legal advice, and not a commitment to lend. Loan approval is not guaranteed. Sources: Expand Realty live MLS statistics for Prosper, TX (Nov 20, 2026); Highland Homes and Toll Brothers price pages (Nov 20, 2026); Collin County Tax Assessor 2026 tax rate summary; Star Trail 2024 HOA and tax sheet; NTTA DNT Phase 4 report (May 2026).

PJ Zaji

PJ Zaji

PJ Zaji, Dallas-Fort Worth Realtor and Texas mortgage loan originator

Back to Blog