
Anna vs Melissa TX (2026): Which Payment Fits You Better?
Updated November 2026 by PJ Zaji, REALTOR and Mortgage Loan Originator
Short answer: Anna is cheaper to buy into, with a $447,772 median list price in November 2026 versus $596,633 in Melissa. Melissa has the lower 2026 base tax rate, about $1.89 per $100 versus $2.00 in Anna, and a larger city homestead exemption. If your budget is under $450,000, Anna usually wins. Above that, compare actual homes.
Anna and Melissa sit side by side on US 75 north of McKinney, and a lot of my buyers tour both on the same Saturday. They feel similar from the highway. On paper, they're quite different, and those differences show up in the payment. Here's how I compare them from the lending side.
How do Anna and Melissa compare on home prices?
Nov 20, 2026 | Anna | Melissa |
|---|---|---|
Homes listed | 578 | 213 |
Median list price | $447,772 | $596,633 |
Price per sq ft | $192 | $228 |
Average days on site | 105 | 95 |
New-construction median | $426,561 (257 homes) | $551,556 (50 homes) |
Anna has almost three times as many listings and about $149,000 less at the median. For a buyer who needs choice under $400,000, that's usually the deciding fact. Builders such as Ashton Woods, Century Communities and Meritage posted Anna plans starting between $352,990 and $393,008 in November 2026.
Which city has lower property taxes?
Melissa, on rate. The 2026 tax year numbers from the Collin County Tax Assessor:
Per $100 (2026) | Anna | Melissa |
|---|---|---|
City rate | $0.548282 | $0.454116 |
City homestead exemption | 3% ($5,000 min) | 6% ($5,000 min) |
School district rate | Anna ISD $1.2158 | Melissa ISD $1.2008 |
Base total with county and college | About $1.9967 | About $1.8876 |
Now look at the same price in both cities. A $450,000 home with a homestead would owe about $7,102 a year in base taxes in Anna and about $6,583 in Melissa. That's roughly $43 a month in Melissa's favor. It's real money, but it won't close a $149,000 price gap. Where it matters is when you're choosing between two homes at the same price.
How do PIDs and MUDs change the comparison?
This is where I see the biggest swings. Collin County's 2026 list includes Anna PIDs named Hurricane Creek, Sherley Tract, Meadow Vista and AnaCapri. A PID adds a fixed yearly installment per lot, which goes into escrow and into the debt-to-income ratio I have to calculate.
On the Melissa side, Bloomfield markets Liberty as "No MUD, No PID". In Anna, Ashton Woods says the same about Coyote Meadows. So each city has communities with and without special districts. I pull the PID notice or tax certificate on every address before we compare payments.
What will I pay for utilities in each city?
Both cities run their own water, sewer and trash billing. Using each city's posted rates at 5,000 gallons:
Anna: the city's sample shows $150.55 for water and wastewater, with trash and recycling billed separately.
Melissa: about $145 for water and sewer, plus $21.50 for solid waste and recycling, before tax.
Melissa bills sewer on your winter-average water use, so summer lawn watering doesn't raise your sewer charge. The utility difference is small either way. I don't count it in qualifying, but I want it in your budget.
Which city is growing faster?
Melissa, by percentage. Census estimates reported in 2026 put Melissa at 29,969 residents, up 14.5% in a year, and Anna at 35,245, up 10.2%. Both were among the fastest-growing U.S. cities of their size. Fast growth means new construction keeps coming, which gives buyers options and builders a reason to offer incentives. It also means roads and schools are catching up, so test your commute and confirm the zoned campuses with Anna ISD or Melissa ISD for each address.
How do the commutes compare?
Both cities sit on US 75, so most drivers head south through McKinney. Melissa also has SH 121 running southwest toward McKinney, which some of my buyers prefer depending on where they work. Anna is the farther north of the two, so for the same destination, the drive is usually a few miles longer. Drive both routes at your real commute hour before choosing.
Is a resale or a new build the better value in each city?
It depends on the city. In Melissa, the cheapest path is often an older resale. A November 2026 snapshot of eight North Creek listings ran from about $270,000 to $449,900, on homes built around 2006. Those homes have no builder incentives, but they usually come with fences, blinds and mature trees, and an FHA or conventional loan on a resale is straightforward.
In Anna, new construction is where the volume is, and builders compete. Builders here often advertise time-limited incentives, such as money toward a rate buydown or closing costs, usually tied to the builder's preferred lender, so ask me which offers are running the week you shop. I compare any builder package with an outside loan, with the APR on each, so you can see which saves more over the years you plan to stay. My builder incentives guide explains how.
Which city should I choose for my budget?
Under $400,000: Anna. It had 13 of the first 24 new-build listings under $400K, compared with 3 in Melissa.
$400,000 to $500,000: both work. Compare an Anna home with a PID against a Melissa home without one, or an older Melissa resale.
$500,000 to $700,000: Melissa deserves a close look. Liberty's no-PID setup and the lower base rate help the monthly payment, and Anna's Villages of Hurricane Creek offers bigger lots in a PID.
How do I compare an Anna home and a Melissa home side by side?
Pick one home in each city from the Anna and Melissa search pages.
I pull both tax records, any PID or MUD notice and both HOA budgets.
I build a full monthly payment for each, with the APR on any rate I quote.
You pick the one that fits, then get pre-approved on it. Approval depends on your income, credit, assets and the property, and is never guaranteed.
For more on each town, see my Anna, TX guide and Melissa, TX guide. Ready to compare two homes? Send them to me.
The Expand Realty blog has the shopper's comparison, Anna TX vs Melissa TX: Homes, Taxes and Market. For a deeper look at each city's new builds, read my new homes under $400K in Anna and Melissa and Melissa new construction costs and financing posts, plus MUD vs PID taxes and the Collin County homestead exemption.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Anna or Melissa cheaper?
Anna is cheaper to buy into, with a $447,772 median versus $596,633 in Melissa on November 20, 2026. Melissa has the lower tax rate.
Which has lower property taxes, Anna or Melissa?
Melissa. Its 2026 base total is about $1.8876 per $100, compared with about $1.9967 in Anna, and its city homestead exemption is 6% versus 3%.
Are Anna and Melissa in the same school district?
No. Anna is mostly Anna ISD and Melissa is mostly Melissa ISD. Confirm the zoned campuses for each address with the district.
Can I get the same payment in Melissa as in Anna?
Only if the homes are close in price. Melissa's lower rate saves roughly $43 a month on a $450,000 home, which doesn't offset a large price difference.
Which city has more new construction?
Anna, with 257 new-build listings on November 20, 2026, versus 50 in Melissa.
PJ Zaji, REALTOR, Monument Realty (TREC #631862), team Expand Realty Group, 3620 The Star Blvd, Suite 1205, Frisco, TX 75034. Mortgage Loan Originator NMLS# 2280005, NEXA Mortgage, LLC NMLS# 1660690. This is general information, not tax or legal advice, and not a commitment to lend. Sources: Expand Realty live MLS statistics for Anna and Melissa, TX (Nov 20, 2026); Collin County Tax Assessor 2026 tax rate summary; City of Anna and City of Melissa utility rates; Community Impact; Ashton Woods, Meritage and Bloomfield pages.
